PROVO, Utah — Lawyers for Tyler Robinson, the man accused of killing political commentator Charlie Kirk, are asking a Utah judge to ban cameras and limit media access in court — a rare move that underscores the intense public scrutiny surrounding the high-profile case.
Both Robinson’s defense team and law enforcement officials have petitioned 4th District Court Judge Tony Graf to prohibit photography and video coverage of future proceedings. The Utah County Sheriff’s Office filed its own request supporting the camera ban, citing security and safety concerns.
Robinson’s attorneys agreed, arguing that restricting courtroom imagery would protect their client’s right to a fair trial and prevent potential jurors from being influenced by his physical appearance or viral media portrayals.
Defense Cites ‘Content Tornado’ and Media Frenzy
Defense filings described what they called a “content tornado” of misinformation and manipulated images that have circulated online since Robinson’s first appearance, where he was seen via video wearing a jail-issued suicide-prevention smock.
According to the defense, thousands of social media posts have exaggerated or fabricated Robinson’s demeanor, including doctored images showing him frowning, crying, or wearing an orange jumpsuit — scenes that never occurred.
“His physical appearance has become the subject of obsessive interest,” the motion states. “Restricting cameras is necessary to preserve his presumption of innocence.”
Law Enforcement and Prosecution Positions
The sheriff’s office also suggested Robinson appear remotely via video feed for future hearings, a proposal the defense strongly opposed. Attorneys argued such an arrangement would hinder Robinson’s ability to engage meaningfully with his defense and the court.
While prosecutors opposed the defense’s separate request for Robinson to appear in plain clothes without shackles, their legal arguments were filed under seal, citing courthouse security details.
Judge Graf has pledged to keep proceedings open to the public while ensuring fairness and decorum. “Justice will be handled with diligence and competence,” he said during an earlier hearing.
Broader Implications and Political Overtones
The case has drawn national attention since Robinson’s arrest for the Sept. 10 shooting of Charlie Kirk during a speaking event at Utah Valley University. Robinson faces seven charges, including aggravated murder, and could face the death penalty if convicted.
The defense cited comments from prominent political figures as evidence of prejudicial pretrial publicity. They referenced statements by former President Donald Trump, who said, “I hope he gets the death penalty,” and Utah Gov. Spencer Cox, who announced, “We got him,” after the arrest.
Legal observers note that such high-level commentary could complicate jury selection and bolster the defense’s argument for stricter courtroom media controls.
A closed hearing is scheduled for Friday, where both sides will privately present their positions on media access, clothing, and other procedural limits.
